The Roger Watts Debate

Roger Watts Debate 2023 Winners: Government. Braeden Gervais and Ayomide Maxwell

2023: Be it resolved that Canada’s affordability crisis justifies a temporary wealth tax.

In a world of division, debate matters. On Wednesday, March 29, 2023 at the Mary Irwin Theatre in Kelowna, BC, top UBC Okanagan student debaters argued their case as part of the Roger Watts Debate.

Students debated the motion Be it resolved that Canada’s affordability crisis justifies a temporary wealth tax before a panel of community judges who decided the winners. Prizes of $1,000 were awarded to the first-place finishers, while prizes of $500 were awarded to the runners-up.


The Roger Watts Debate is a partnership of the Department of Economics, Philosophy and Political Science and a community advisory committee. The debate provides a public forum to debate important issues of the day.


The Roger Watts Debate is made possible through the generous support of:

SPONSOR

Vancouver International Arbitration Center

SUPPORTERS

Walley Lightbody QC, Sandra Watts, Roger Watts Jr., Central Okanagan Foundation, UBCO Debate Society

2023 Student Debater Profiles

Name: Braeden Gervais
Position: Prime Minister — Government
Program: B.A. in Philosophy, Politics and Economics  |  4th Year

Braeden is the President of UBCO’s Debate Society and has won the Roger Watts Debate twice prior.

Deliberation and debate is the way you stir the soul of our democracy.” — Jesse Jackson

Name: Ayomide Maxwell
Position: Deputy Prime Minister — Government
Program: Psychology  |  3rd Year

Ayomide MaxwellAyo was raised by Nigerian parents in London, England, before moving to Alberta in 2014. Ayo spent his youth as an athlete excelling in basketball, weightlifting, track and football, to name a few. While majoring in psychology in his first year at McGill University, Ayo’s life took an unfortunate turn as he faced false criminal allegations. After understanding the prominence of false allegations compared to the misconception that they ‘rarely happen,’ he was disgusted.

In this time of strife, he vowed to be the light shining in the darkness for young black men facing baseless allegations. In working towards this goal, he has engaged in Model UN, Pre-law Society,

Black Excellence Society and others to best prepare himself for the difficulties of such an endeavour. In addition, to achieve his goal, he is starting at Peter A Allard School of Law at UBC in the Fall of 2023. With the aim to fight for innocent individuals in defamation trials and/or criminal court, public speaking is a critical skill he seeks to develop through events like the Roger Watts Debate.

Take a traumatic event you went through as a child; now design someone who would be the perfect solution to fix what you were going through. Now go become the hero you wish you had.”

Name: Chanidu Gamage
Position: Leader — Opposition
Program: Philosophy and Political Science  |  3rd Year

Chanidu GamageChanidu Gamage is a 3rd-year philosophy and political science student and an Ethics and Public Policy Center intern. He serves on the Campaign Life Coalition Youth executive committee and the National March for Life youth organizing committee. Gamage’s writing has been published in The Wall Street Journal, Israel Hayom, and the Jewish News Syndicate.

Before joining EPPC, he worked as a public affairs intern at Crestview Strategy. Previously, Gamage was a legislative intern to Congressman Matt Rosendale (R-MT). He started in politics working for MP Pierre Paul-Hus and, later, MP Tracy Gray.

Gamage has been awarded fellowships from McKinsey & Company; The Heritage Foundation; Alliance Defending Freedom; First Liberty Institute; Center for Religion, Culture, and Democracy; Stennis Center for Public Service; and Canadian Jewish Political Affairs Committee.

He is an adult convert to Catholicism. Gamage is a proud Nova Scotian.

“I am completely opposed to the error of the modernists…” — Saint Pius 

Name: Trinity Schredl
Position: Deputy Leader — Opposition
Program: Political Science  |  4th Year

Trinity SchredlTrinity Schredl is going into law, and is excited to participate in the 2023 Roger Watts Debate.

“It is better to debate a question without settling it than to settle a question without debating it.” — Joseph Joubert

Name: Mihai Covaser
Position: Alternate — Government
Program: Philosophy, Politics and Economics (PPE) / French  |  2nd Year

Mihai Covaser has five years of debate experience, including several live and online tournament wins. Most recently, he won the inaugural Worlds Schools Online Debate Championship hosted by former Team Canada debater Iqbal Kasam with his teammates from Kelowna Secondary School. He has been teaching with the Debate Camp summer camp program for two years, helping students achieve their public speaking and debate potential through teaching and activity leading. Mihai is passionate about accessibility and inclusion in his community, using his skills as a speaker to advocate for change for youths with disabilities, particularly in the education system. His most recent project is the Help Teach podcast, designed to offer educators concrete action items they can apply to make the classroom more accessible. Mihai is pursuing a double major in hopes of applying to McGill Law School in 2025, with the ultimate goal of becoming a judge in the Supreme Court of Canada.

“Non nobis solum nati sumus (Not for ourselves alone are we born).” — Cicero 

Name: Ideja Efendija
Position: Alternate — Opposition
Program: International Relations  |  3rd Year

Ideja Efendija

Ideja Efendija is a 3rd-year international student majoring in international relations. Originally from Kosovo, Ideja has lived most of her life in Kenya. Ideja’s passions include political science, content creation, and writing.

“There is no easy way from the earth to the stars.” — Seneca

About the Debate

Interested in participating in the debate?

Students, please contact Trinity for information on training: ubcodebatesociety@gmail.com.

A Roger Watts Debate has been held annually, beginning in 2014. Resolutions and participants during the first six years have been as follows:

2023: Be it resolved that Canada’s affordability crisis justifies a temporary wealth tax.

Government:
Braeden Gervais, Ayomide Maxwell (winners)

Opposition:
Chanidu Gamage, Trinity Schredl

Alternates:
Mihai Covaser, Ideja Efendija


2022: Be it resolved that the Emergencies Act is justifiably used to quell civil disobedience.

Government:
Braeden Gervais, Heather Sham

Opposition:
Ideja Efendija, Toney Bedell (winners)

Alternates:
Lakshay Karnwal, Mihai Covaser

People’s Choice Award: Toney Bedell


2021: Be it resolved that the government should have the ability to make vaccination mandatory

Government:
Christine Semeniuk, Toney Bedell

Opposition:
Braeden Gervais, Lakshay Karnwal (Winners)

Alternates:
Trinity Schredl, Brendan Stewart

People’s Choice Award:
Christine Semeniuk


2020: Be it resolved that technology is our best answer to climate change

Finalists – Cowinners:
Kathleen Lortie, Braeden Gervais, Toney Bedell, Nicole Michalewicz

Alternates:
Christine Semeniuk, Nathan Romanchych


2019: Be it resolved that Canada needs more pipelines

Government:
Christine Semeniuk, Michaela Sullivan-Paul

Opposition:
Toney Bedell, Nick Huertas (Winners)

Alternates:
Mackenzie Edwards, Davis Tessema


2018: Be it resolved that Western democracies are failing

Government:
Tyrel Lamoureux, Jason Wu

Opposition:
Mackenzie Edwards, Laura Fylyshtan (Winners)

Alternates:
Brett Shaigec, Michaela Sullivan-Paul


2017: Be it resolved that personalities have replaced issues in politics

Government:
Tyrel Lamoureux, Laurence Watt

Opposition:
Michael Flood, Nicole Tomasic (Winners)

Alternates:
Jordan Britnell, Mackenzie Edwards


2016: Be it resolved that Canada has an obligation to take refugees

Government:
Lina Gomez, Daniel Kandie

Opposition:
Sarah Nunis, Kimberly Owuor (Winners)

Alternates:
Alana Firedancer, Richard McCurrach


2015: Be it resolved that government surveillance is justified

Government:
Kevin Ilomin, Ayla Lovell

Opposition:
Sutheeksan (Dixon) Sunthoram, Laurence Watt (Winners)

Alternates:
Alina Malicki Casas, Tyrel Lamoureux


2014: Be it resolved that social media brings us closer

Government:
Maisha Maliha Badhon, Jordan Kostaschuk

Opposition:
Kathryn Helmore, David MacLean (Winners)

Alternate:
Kevin Ilomin

The standard format used for Roger Watts Debates has been as follows:

(i) Opening remarks

(ii) Introductions

(iii) Debate

Prime Minister five minutes opening
Leader of the Opposition five minutes opening
Deputy Prime Minister eight minutes response
Deputy Leader of the Opposition eight minutes response
Rapid Fire Round eight minutes (no speaker to exceed two minutes)
Leader of the Opposition three minutes
Prime Minister three minutes

All UBCO undergraduate students are invited to enroll in the Roger Watts debate runoffs. To enroll, students simply need to express interest by emailing Dr. Julien Picault before March 1 at noon.

Students are paired in teams of two representing both sides – Government and Opposition

The debate will be conducted as follows:

  • Prime Minister
  • Leader of the Opposition
  • Deputy Prime Minister
  • Deputy leader of the Opposition
  • Open Debate
  • Deputy Prime Minister
  • Deputy leader of the Opposition
  • Prime Minister
  • Leader of the Opposition

All instructions, debate teams, and motions will be sent about a week before the Runoffs.

Roger Watts

Roger Dennis Watts
1945-2011

Born in Scotland in 1945, Roger was a well-travelled child having lived between Britain, Canada and California before moving to Africa in 1953. He fondly remembered his youth spent in Rhodesia and South Africa prior to his return to Canada in 1958. He handled the relocations by developing a charm to captivate new friends everywhere he went.

Known by all who had the opportunity to spend time with him as a man of compassion, energy and generosity, he truly savoured each day and lived life to the fullest. He lit up any room he entered with his unabashed, hearty laughter and his infectious enthusiasm for life. He loved to be surrounded by friends and family, an audience for his copious stories. He was always up for adventure and loved travelling, playing tennis and sailing. A true romantic, he embraced his dreams as well as the dreams and passions of those around him.

Roger obtained both his bachelor and Law degrees from the University of British Columbia.  Called to the British Columbia Bar in May, 1975, he then moved to the Okanagan to start his first law practice and to raise his family. Roger practiced personal injury law focusing on complex brain & spinal injuries and chronic pain with an emphasis on jury trials.

He developed a long and successful career as a trial lawyer filled with unbridled passion.

In Roger’s words:
“I endeavor to meet each of my clients with compassion to listen and learn about you, your background, your family and your dreams for the future.

I am also committed to fighting passionately on your behalf against administration, rules and the system, and to communicate to the court that you are not just a number in the queue, but an individual who matters with real hardship.”

Roger loved to teach and mentored many articling students who aspired to be trial lawyers.  He spoke about the powers of advocacy as a guest lecturer on Contemporary Canadian Law in the Political Science department at UBCO. It is very fitting that an endowment fund set up in his memory is now supporting young advocates of the future. 

Read the article published in The Advocate by Walley Lightbody, Q.C., and Roger Watts Jr.

Julien Picault

PROFESSOR, ECONOMICS

Phone: 250.807.9227
Email:  julien.picault@ubc.ca

 

UBCO Debate Society

UBC Okanagan’s Debate Society is a non-competitive group of students who meet weekly to practice the art of debate. Welcoming students from any faculty, the Debate Society gives students of all abilities a fun way to develop their oracy skills. Every week the executive team puts on different activities and lessons to help students with their critical thinking skills and to build up confident communication.

The Debate Society also enlists the help of mentors, who are professors and other local community members, to give feedback and comment on the students’ practices. The Debate Society also aims to help students to become more informed about political and global affairs. Although the society offers some competitive opportunities, UBC Okanagan’s main competition is the annual Roger Watts Debate Competition where students have the opportunity to try out and debate in the community for cash prizes. All-in-all, the Debate Society is a great way to get involved on campus, meet new people, and develop the skills of debate.

Learn More

Watch on the Real Deal

Donate

The event is made possible through our generous donors and community sponsors. Donations are welcome and payable to the Central Okanagan Foundation Roger Watts Debate Fund. Donate by selecting “Watts, Roger Memorial Fund” from the drop-down menu.

DONATE NOW